Skip to main content

Shopping Neighborhood

Earl Plaza | Lafayette

400 N Earl Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904

Listing Price: $1,826,216

Cap Rate
8.12%
Gross SF
17,400
Rentable SF
17,400
Price/Gross SF
$104.95
Lot Size
1.35 acres
Year Built
1977

Investment Overview

Earl Plaza offers attractive lease terms, with all tenants on net leases, recent renewals featuring strong annual rent increases, and new leasing momentum from four tenants who signed in 2024–2025. Currently 82% occupied, the property presents meaningful add-value potential through a 3,200 SF freestanding vacancy. Below-market rents, combined with several tenants lacking renewal options, create an opportunity to increase rents significantly in the near term. The center is positioned just off Lafayette’s prime retail corridors—Sagamore Pkwy N (23,797 VPD) and South St (25,601 VPD)—and is surrounded by new retail developments and major national tenants. Nearby, Lafayette Pavilions ranks in the top 5% of shopping centers nationwide by visits and attracts 5.1 million annual visitors. The trade area is both dense and expanding, with nearly 74,000 residents and more than 107,000 workers within three miles, and continued population growth projected.

Investment Highlights

  • New leasing momentum | Two tenants recently renewed leases and two additional tenants signed new leases in 2024 and 2025
  • Six out of eight tenants feature annual rental increases | One additional tenant to begin rental increases at their option (Sandy's Beauty Supply)
  • 82% occupied neighborhood center with add-value opportunities
  • Located just off the prime retail corridor of Lafayette
  • Ample amount of new construction in the area, including a Raising Cane's, Wawa, and Dutch Bro's Coffee
  • 1.8 miles from Lafayette Pavilions, which ranks in the top 5% of shopping centers nationwide by visits and attracts 5.1 million annual visitors (Placer.ai)
  • 73,697 people live and 107,571 people work within a three-mile radius

Exclusively Listed By

Broker of Record

  • Josh Caruana

    First Vice President/Regional Manager

    (317) 218-5300

    License(s) IN: RB14034355

    Indiana

Financing By

Shopping Neighborhood

Earl Plaza | Lafayette

Listing Price: $1,826,216

Cap Rate
8.12%
Gross SF
17,400
Rentable SF
17,400
Price/Gross SF
$104.95
Lot Size
1.35 acres
Year Built
1977

Investment Highlights

  • New leasing momentum | Two tenants recently renewed leases and two additional tenants signed new leases in 2024 and 2025
  • Six out of eight tenants feature annual rental increases | One additional tenant to begin rental increases at their option (Sandy's Beauty Supply)
  • 82% occupied neighborhood center with add-value opportunities
  • Located just off the prime retail corridor of Lafayette
  • Ample amount of new construction in the area, including a Raising Cane's, Wawa, and Dutch Bro's Coffee
  • 1.8 miles from Lafayette Pavilions, which ranks in the top 5% of shopping centers nationwide by visits and attracts 5.1 million annual visitors (Placer.ai)
  • 73,697 people live and 107,571 people work within a three-mile radius

Investment Overview

Earl Plaza offers attractive lease terms, with all tenants on net leases, recent renewals featuring strong annual rent increases, and new leasing momentum from four tenants who signed in 2024–2025. Currently 82% occupied, the property presents meaningful add-value potential through a 3,200 SF freestanding vacancy. Below-market rents, combined with several tenants lacking renewal options, create an opportunity to increase rents significantly in the near term. The center is positioned just off Lafayette’s prime retail corridors—Sagamore Pkwy N (23,797 VPD) and South St (25,601 VPD)—and is surrounded by new retail developments and major national tenants. Nearby, Lafayette Pavilions ranks in the top 5% of shopping centers nationwide by visits and attracts 5.1 million annual visitors. The trade area is both dense and expanding, with nearly 74,000 residents and more than 107,000 workers within three miles, and continued population growth projected.

Exclusively Listed By

Broker of Record

  • Josh Caruana

    First Vice President/Regional Manager

    (317) 218-5300

    License(s): IN: RB14034355

    Indiana

Financing By

MM Texture Background
MM Textured Background Lower