Skip to main content

Shopping Strip

AUCTION - Westgate Plaza

5173 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241

Starting Bid: $2,000,000

Gross SF
61,469
Rentable SF
61,469
Price/Gross SF
$32.54
Lot Size
10.24 acres
Year Built
1975
Auction Type
Reserve
Auction Start Date
Jun 22, 2026
Auction End Date
Jun 24, 2026

Investment Overview

Register to bid and access due diligence documents on RealINSIGHT Marketplace: https://rimarketplace.com/auction/2636

Marcus & Millichap, in partnership with RealINSIGHT Marketplace, is pleased to present Westgate Plaza, a 66,469 SF grocery-anchored community shopping center in the heart of Indianapolis, Indiana. The Property is 97% occupied and anchored by a long-standing Kroger that occupies 74% of GLA, contributes 60% of gross income, and generates approximately 877,000 annual customer visits, ranking in the top 25% nationally on a visits-per-SF basis. The Kroger fuel outparcel and drive-thru pharmacy enhance customer draw, while a newly signed 7-year lease with Humana CenterWell Senior Primary Care at $16/SF NNN adds a strong medical traffic component. Five long-standing small-shop tenants, including Papa John's and H&R Block, contribute stable, recurring income, and 6 of 7 tenants occupying 94% of GLA are national brands. All tenants are on NNN leases with 91.4% recovery of landlord expenses, delivering operational efficiency and upside through the lease-up of a 1,900 SF vacancy. Strategically located 0.8 miles from I-465 along the high-traffic W. Washington Street corridor (20,700 VPD) with 550 feet of frontage and a signalized entrance, the Property sits in a densely populated trade area within an Indianapolis MSA that has grown 13.4% since 2010. Priced well below replacement cost, Westgate Plaza is positioned for durable cash flow and long-term value creation.

Investment Highlights

  • Auction - June 22-24, 2026 | Starting Bid: $2,000,000
  • 97% Occupied, 66,469 SF Grocery-Anchored Community Shopping Center in Indianapolis, IN
  • Anchored by Kroger with Current Term thru August 2027; Occupies 74% of GLA and Contributes 60% of Center's Gross Income
  • 40+ Years of Operating History at Site; Tenant Since 1981 with History of Numerous Renewals
  • 877K Annual Customer Visits, Ranking #8 (Top 16%) of 46 Kroger Stores in a 30-Mi Radius based on Visits/SF
  • Ranks Top 25% Both in Indiana and Nationally Based on Visits/SF
  • Low Rent of $5.83/SF NNN ($9.00/SF All-in)
  • Has Kroger Fuel Outparcel and Offers Drive-Thru Pharmacy

Exclusively Listed By

Broker of Record

  • Julia Evinger

    Managing Director Investments

    (317) 218-5300

    License(s) IN: RB14040143

    Indiana

Shopping Strip

AUCTION - Westgate Plaza

Starting Bid: $2,000,000

Gross SF
61,469
Rentable SF
61,469
Price/Gross SF
$32.54
Lot Size
10.24 acres
Year Built
1975
Auction Type
Reserve
Auction Start Date
Jun 22, 2026
Auction End Date
Jun 24, 2026

Investment Highlights

  • Auction - June 22-24, 2026 | Starting Bid: $2,000,000
  • 97% Occupied, 66,469 SF Grocery-Anchored Community Shopping Center in Indianapolis, IN
  • Anchored by Kroger with Current Term thru August 2027; Occupies 74% of GLA and Contributes 60% of Center's Gross Income
  • 40+ Years of Operating History at Site; Tenant Since 1981 with History of Numerous Renewals
  • 877K Annual Customer Visits, Ranking #8 (Top 16%) of 46 Kroger Stores in a 30-Mi Radius based on Visits/SF
  • Ranks Top 25% Both in Indiana and Nationally Based on Visits/SF
  • Low Rent of $5.83/SF NNN ($9.00/SF All-in)
  • Has Kroger Fuel Outparcel and Offers Drive-Thru Pharmacy

Investment Overview

Register to bid and access due diligence documents on RealINSIGHT Marketplace: https://rimarketplace.com/auction/2636 Marcus & Millichap, in partnership with RealINSIGHT Marketplace, is pleased to present Westgate Plaza, a 66,469 SF grocery-anchored community shopping center in the heart of Indianapolis, Indiana. The Property is 97% occupied and anchored by a long-standing Kroger that occupies 74% of GLA, contributes 60% of gross income, and generates approximately 877,000 annual customer visits, ranking in the top 25% nationally on a visits-per-SF basis. The Kroger fuel outparcel and drive-thru pharmacy enhance customer draw, while a newly signed 7-year lease with Humana CenterWell Senior Primary Care at $16/SF NNN adds a strong medical traffic component. Five long-standing small-shop tenants, including Papa John's and H&R Block, contribute stable, recurring income, and 6 of 7 tenants occupying 94% of GLA are national brands. All tenants are on NNN leases with 91.4% recovery of landlord expenses, delivering operational efficiency and upside through the lease-up of a 1,900 SF vacancy. Strategically located 0.8 miles from I-465 along the high-traffic W. Washington Street corridor (20,700 VPD) with 550 feet of frontage and a signalized entrance, the Property sits in a densely populated trade area within an Indianapolis MSA that has grown 13.4% since 2010. Priced well below replacement cost, Westgate Plaza is positioned for durable cash flow and long-term value creation.

Exclusively Listed By

Broker of Record

  • Julia Evinger

    Managing Director Investments

    (317) 218-5300

    License(s): IN: RB14040143

    Indiana

MM Texture Background
MM Textured Background Lower