Skip to main content

Mixed-Use

Auction - Middletown Value-Add Redevelopment | UC-C Zoned, Tax Credit Potential

34 S Main St, Middletown, OH 45044

Starting Bid: $1

Rentable SF
29,492
Lot Size
0.24 acres
Year Built
1831
Auction Type
Absolute
Auction Start Date
Nov 17, 2026
Auction End Date
Nov 19, 2026

Investment Overview

Register to bid and access due diligence documents on RealINSIGHT Marketplace: https://rimarketplace.com/auction/3468

34 S Main St, Middletown, OH 45044 is the former U.S. Hotel, a three-story, 29,492 SF historic building on a 0.24-acre fee simple parcel in the heart of downtown Middletown. Originally constructed in 1831 as a coffee house and residence and converted to the U.S. Hotel in 1845, the property is a contributing structure within a National Register Historic District and was most recently operated as a mixed-use building with street-level retail and residential on the upper floors. The investment thesis centers on adaptive reuse: UC-C (Urban Center Core) zoning permits hotel, office, retail, multifamily residential, mixed-use, and live-work concepts, giving a buyer flexibility to restore, reposition, or redevelop the building around the strongest exit. Contributing-structure status creates potential eligibility for historic preservation tax credits. The Main Street location places the asset within Middletown's urban core, with regional access via I-75 and Dayton International Airport, and a 5-mile trade area of 81,831 residents and 33,799 households.

Auctioneer: Thomas Seaman, License #2007000016

Investment Highlights

  • Absolute Auction - November 17-19 | Starting Bid: $1
  • 29,492 SF Downtown Main Street Landmark
  • Flexible UC-C Zoning & Multiple Exits
  • 81,831 Residents Within Five Miles
  • A Head Start on Redevelopment
  • Potential Historic Preservation Tax Credits
  • Courtyard Expands Redevelopment Options

Exclusively Listed By

Auction Advisors

Mixed-Use

Auction - Middletown Value-Add Redevelopment | UC-C Zoned, Tax Credit Potential

Starting Bid: $1

Rentable SF
29,492
Lot Size
0.24 acres
Year Built
1831
Auction Type
Absolute
Auction Start Date
Nov 17, 2026
Auction End Date
Nov 19, 2026

Investment Highlights

  • Absolute Auction - November 17-19 | Starting Bid: $1
  • 29,492 SF Downtown Main Street Landmark
  • Flexible UC-C Zoning & Multiple Exits
  • 81,831 Residents Within Five Miles
  • A Head Start on Redevelopment
  • Potential Historic Preservation Tax Credits
  • Courtyard Expands Redevelopment Options

Investment Overview

Register to bid and access due diligence documents on RealINSIGHT Marketplace: https://rimarketplace.com/auction/3468 34 S Main St, Middletown, OH 45044 is the former U.S. Hotel, a three-story, 29,492 SF historic building on a 0.24-acre fee simple parcel in the heart of downtown Middletown. Originally constructed in 1831 as a coffee house and residence and converted to the U.S. Hotel in 1845, the property is a contributing structure within a National Register Historic District and was most recently operated as a mixed-use building with street-level retail and residential on the upper floors. The investment thesis centers on adaptive reuse: UC-C (Urban Center Core) zoning permits hotel, office, retail, multifamily residential, mixed-use, and live-work concepts, giving a buyer flexibility to restore, reposition, or redevelop the building around the strongest exit. Contributing-structure status creates potential eligibility for historic preservation tax credits. The Main Street location places the asset within Middletown's urban core, with regional access via I-75 and Dayton International Airport, and a 5-mile trade area of 81,831 residents and 33,799 households.

Auctioneer: Thomas Seaman, License #2007000016

Exclusively Listed By

Auction Advisors

MM Texture Background
MM Textured Background Lower